StoneEagleDATA: F&I Anchors Deal Profitability in the First Half
StoneEagleDATA's first-half 2025 F&I Benchmarks show stronger PVR and higher total gross, even as front-end gross compressed.
Deals stayed profitable in the first half of 2025, even as sales departments struggled to hold gross. With front-end margins under pressure, F&I offices anchored total deal profitability, according to StoneEagleDATA's latest benchmarks drawn from more than 8,900 dealer rooftops.
"From a snapshot perspective, Q2 looks beautiful," said StoneEagle CEO Cindy Allen in the Automotive News-hosted webinar. "All the key performance indicators are up year-over-year, and the resiliency of F&I is what's driving profitability."

Front-End Pressure Meets Back-End Strength
Vehicle sales moderated after what Allen called "the March Madness spike," but still outpaced seasonal norms. The bigger story was margin pressure: front-end gross has been sliding since early 2024.
Yet compared to pre-COVID levels, grosses remain significantly higher — averaging $694 in the first half of 2025 versus $404 before the pandemic, a 72% increase.
That long-term context helps, but the real profit story came from the back end — back-end gross more than filled the gap. "Despite a 40% reduction in front gross in 2024, F&I product sales softened that to only an 11% impact," Allen explained. "In 2025, total gross per vehicle is already up 10% year-to-date. That's the stabilizer F&I offices are providing."
Products Fueling the Anchor
Service contracts and GAP remain the backbone, holding strong in the first half with penetration rates of 45% and 38%, respectively. But ancillary products now account for a third of F&I product revenue, driven by protection packages, prepaid maintenance, and tire-and-wheel.
F&I's Top 5 by Penetration Rate (H1 2025 vs. H1 2024)
Service Contract: 45% (↑ from 44%)
GAP: 38% (↑ from 37%)
Paint & Fabric: 20% (↑ from 19%)
Prepaid Maintenance: 16% (flat)
Tire & Wheel: 10% (flat)
F&I's Top 5 by Penetration Rate (Q2 2025 vs. Q2 2024)
Service Contract: 45% (↑ from 44%)
GAP: 38% (↑ from 37%)
Paint & Fabric: 20% (↑ from 19%)
Prepaid Maintenance: 16% (flat)
Tire & Wheel: 11% (↑ from 10%)
"Packaging products together — tire and wheel, key, dent, paint-and-fabric — has been one of the fastest-growing trends of the past 18 months," Allen said. "Consumers want to protect their resale value, and that's showing up in the data."
The revenue mix inside F&I offices reflects the shift. In 2021, product and reserve were nearly equal. Today, products account for 66% of F&I revenue, underscoring the significant role product sales play in maintaining total deal profitability.
The Numbers Behind the Story
Quarterly (Q2 vs. Q1 2025):
F&I PVR: $1,924 (+4.6%)
Products per Deal: 1.57 (+2.0%)
Avg. Monthly F&I Income per Dealer: $220,640 (+7.7%)
Deal Count: 115 (+3.6%)
First Half (2025 vs. 2024):
F&I PVR: $1,884 (+6.1%)
Products per Deal: 1.55 (+2.0%)
Avg. Monthly F&I Income per Dealer: $212,759 (+7.5%)
Avg. Monthly Deal Count: 113 (+1.4%)
"Despite tariffs, interest rates, and affordability pressures, F&I is proving just how strong and adaptable it is," Allen said. "The first half of 2025 has outperformed every prior year in our dataset — even the big post-COVID spike."
Watch the Webinar On-Demand
See the full charts, long-term comparisons, and Cindy Allen's commentary in our 20-minute Automotive News-hosted webinar. 👉 Watch Now
StoneEagleDATA: Powering the Industry
Drawing data from over 8,900 dealer rooftops, StoneEagleDATA delivers unmatched visibility into dealership performance:
Comprehensive Benchmarking: StoneEagleDATA captures every transaction and every product from over 50% of the market.
Actionable Insights: Identify trends and opportunities with real-time visibility into F&I product penetration, pricing, and dealer KPIs.
AI-Ready Intelligence: Power propensity models and performance forecasting with dealer-level data you can trust.
Ready to see how this data can work for you? Fill out the form below and let’s start the conversation.



Tracking deal margins and business metrics always comes down to having clear steps. When I was balancing my small business accounts, handling digital payments got pretty confusing. I had some SXP sitting in a wallet and needed USDT for suppliers, but manual chain choices made me nervous. A friend sent me a plain educational resource with a simple walkthrough on how to swap SXP for USDT. It explains non-custodial tools, floating rates, and picking low-fee routes like TRC20 without jargon. Good technical breakdowns make routine tasks so much easier to handle.