F&I PVR Gains Put Repair Costs in Focus

StoneEagleDATA finds higher income per F&I product sold amid relatively flat product sales, as vehicle maintenance expenses and dealership labor rates also continue climbing.
By Gregory Arroyo

F&I profit per vehicle retailed (PVR) accounted for approximately 81% of total gross per deal in the third quarter of 2026. That’s a remarkable share, considering the average number of F&I products sold per deal has barely changed in four years.
Yet F&I PVR has continued to climb, supported in part by rising income per product sold. And those gains are occurring alongside vehicle maintenance and repair costs that have been rising faster than overall inflation.
According to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS), consumer prices for motor vehicle maintenance and repair increased 31.6% between September 2022 and September 2026. Separately, the National Automobile Dealers Association (NADA) reports that average dealership labor rates rose 26.3% from 2022 through the first half of 2026.
StoneEagleDATA’s latest analysis puts those developments side by side, offering a broader view of F&I product income growth as consumers face rising vehicle ownership costs.
More Income Without More Products
Between 2019 and 2022, F&I growth was accompanied by a substantial increase in products sold per deal. The average rose 19% to 1.56 products per deal, while F&I PVR climbed 43% to $1,900. F&I PVR has continued to grow since then, though at a slower pace, rising nearly 4% to $1,975 by the third quarter of 2026 — even as products per deal declined 2.6% to 1.52. That’s the lowest quarterly average since the third quarter of 2024.
Income from F&I products sold offers part of the answer. A comparison of the 2022 annual average with the first nine months of 2026 shows that average income per contract increased across all 12 F&I product categories tracked by StoneEagleDATA. Ten recorded double-digit gains, even as seven categories experienced declining penetration rates.

Tire and Wheel illustrates the difference: Income per contract increased 23.3%, while penetration declined 1.51 percentage points. Vehicle service contracts (VSCs) showed a similar pattern, with income per contract rising 10.7% despite a 1.32-point decline in penetration. Prepaid Maintenance income increased 10.8%, while penetration slipped 0.48 points. Key Replacement and Dent Repair also recorded double-digit income gains, with slightly lower penetration rates.
The latest year-over-year figures show average income per F&I product sold increased 4.9% to approximately $844 in the first nine months of 2026, compared with the same period in 2025. VSC income per contract rose 4.3% to $1,574.
Repair Costs Outpace Inflation
Tariffs and their potential impact on replacement-parts prices are one consideration when examining rising repair costs and F&I product income. But parts tell only part of the story. Dealership labor rates have risen considerably faster, with NADA reporting a 26.3% increase, or an additional $40 per hour, bringing the average to $192 in the first half of 2026. By comparison, BLS reports that consumer prices for motor vehicle parts and equipment increased just 5.5% between September 2022 and September 2026.
StoneEagleDATA also examined how rising repair costs compare with increases in F&I product income. Using an index that measures percentage changes since early 2024, the analysis compared average income per F&I product sold with BLS maintenance and repair prices, parts prices, and NADA dealership labor rates.
By the third quarter of 2026, maintenance and repair prices had risen 15.8%, compared with an 11.5% increase in average income per F&I product sold. Parts and equipment prices increased 5.5%, while NADA dealership labor rates rose 11% between the first halves of 2024 and 2026. Unlike the other measures, NADA reports annual and first-half figures rather than quarterly data.

As StoneEagle CEO Cindy Allen noted during the company’s third-quarter webinar, rising income per F&I contract must also be viewed against the costs associated with the products themselves. For VSCs, prepaid maintenance, and other products covering repair or replacement expenses, higher parts and labor costs can influence the cost of providing that protection.
The index does not establish how much of the increase in income per contract can be attributed to rising repair costs. What it does show is why income per F&I product sold cannot be considered in isolation from the expenses underlying the coverage.
That’s The Complete Picture, brought to you by StoneEagle — your one true source for benchmarks and data that help drive success for your business.
Complete the form below to sign up for the TCP Report newsletter, our monthly briefing on the latest benchmarks and industry data.



Vehicle ownership expenses have definitely climbed noticeably over the last couple of years, especially when minor maintenance turns into a bigger bill. Just last month, while comparing repair quotes and coverage options for a small windshield issue before winter hit, I looked up https://safelite-autoglass.pissedconsumer.com/review.html to see how other drivers handled scheduling and costs. Seeing how service rates and protection plans line up in real life makes budgeting for car upkeep much easier