top of page

Q3 2026 By the Numbers: F&I Defies the Declines

Writer: StoneEagle
StoneEagle
2 days ago
4 min read

Updated: 2 days ago

Amid softer dealership results, F&I continued to play a critical role. But the latest benchmarks reveal changes beneath its strong performance that warrant attention.

By Gregory Arroyo



Three of StoneEagleDATA’s four headline benchmarks for dealership sales and F&I performance declined from a year earlier. All four slipped from the previous quarter, something that hasn’t happened since 2022.


However, third-quarter results hardly suggest the car business is in retreat. Dealership sales were virtually unchanged from Q2, F&I profit per vehicle retailed (PVR) remained near historic highs, and average monthly F&I income per dealer finished just 0.6% below last year’s level.


StoneEagle CEO Cindy Allen examined the third-quarter results and their historical context during the company’s latest quarterly performance webinar. The analysis draws on StoneEagleDATA’s 100% transaction-level data, representing more than half of U.S. franchised dealership rooftops.


A Recovery With Limits

Front-end gross per deal wasn’t among the four headline benchmarks, and its third-quarter decline was considerably larger. The average fell nearly 18% from the second quarter to $466. Compared with the third quarter of 2025, front-end gross declined 16.8%.


Those comparisons tell only part of the story. Front-end gross reached a low of $279 per deal in December 2025 before more than doubling to $609 in April 2026. The recovery lost some ground during the summer, with September finishing at $455, still 63.5% above December’s low.



The longer history provides context for both the decline and recovery. Front-end gross reached $2,746 per deal in January 2022 during the post-pandemic vehicle shortage. September’s $455 was approximately 83% below that level but remained 13% above January 2019’s $404.


The movement in front-end gross also needs to be considered alongside the affordability challenges reflected in StoneEagleDATA’s auto finance data. In the third quarter, average monthly payments exceeded $700, while the average amount financed climbed by $1,335 from a year earlier to $38,255. 


A longer-term comparison of monthly figures reveals how those affordability pressures have developed. Between January 2024 and September 2026, average contract interest rates declined from 8.21% to 7.75%. Yet the average amount financed increased by $4,767 to $38,367, while average monthly payments rose 7%, from $656 to $704. Lower rates haven't translated into lower monthly payments.


For Allen, those affordability challenges are also evident in the third-quarter F&I results. With consumers already stretching their budgets to buy a vehicle, she believes they’re making tougher choices about how much they can afford to spend on products designed to protect it.


F&I’s Affordability Test

The affordability pressures Allen described are not immediately evident in F&I PVR. The third-quarter average increased 2.3% from a year earlier to $1,975, remaining near historic highs.


F&I PVR reached those highs following a 13.4% increase over eight quarters, from early 2024 through the end of 2025. November 2025 marked the first time it surpassed $2,000, reaching a monthly record of $2,025. Growth has since leveled off, with the quarterly average declining just 1% from Q4 2025 to Q3 2026. Allen believes the benchmark is settling into what she calls a new normal.



But the nearly $2,000 average conceals signs of slowing product sales. Products per deal have declined for three consecutive quarters, falling from 1.58 at the end of 2025 to 1.52 in the third quarter of 2026. That’s virtually unchanged from early 2024, even though F&I PVR has increased 12.2% since then.


Product penetration rates offer further evidence of the choices Allen described. Seven of the 12 F&I product categories StoneEagleDATA tracks recorded year-over-year declines in Q3. VSC, GAP, and prepaid maintenance maintained or modestly improved penetration, but GAP stood out, increasing 1.1 percentage points to 39%. Allen pointed to rising negative equity in vehicle loans as one reason consumers continue to value GAP coverage.


What’s keeping F&I PVR elevated is the income dealerships generate from the products they sell. Average income per product increased 11.5% from Q1 2024 to Q3 2026, while 10 of 12 categories recorded double-digit income-per-contract growth since 2022. (Read how rising repair costs put F&I product income gains into perspective.)


Higher F&I PVR has also kept average monthly F&I income per dealer close to last year’s levels despite fewer vehicle sales. After year-over-year increases of 2.8% in the first quarter and 2.4% in the second, average monthly F&I income per dealer slipped 0.6% to $222,124 in the third. Average deals per dealer fell more sharply, declining 2.8% to 112.5. Allen noted the relatively small change in monthly F&I income given the reduction in transactions.



Total gross per deal averaged $2,442 in the third quarter, down 2% from a year earlier. Higher F&I PVR offset part of the decline in front-end gross, with F&I accounting for approximately 81% of total gross per deal.


That share was approximately 64% in January 2024. The increase says as much about the decline in front-end gross as it does about the gains in F&I PVR. For Allen, the third-quarter figures reinforce the stability F&I has provided, even as total gross per deal remains below earlier levels.


That’s The Complete Picture, brought to you by StoneEagle — your one true source for benchmarks and data that help drive success for your business.

 

Complete the form below to sign up for the TCP Report newsletter, our monthly briefing on the latest benchmarks and industry data.


 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page